POLLS     NHL     FACEBOOK

HOUSE OF HOCKEY


Edmonton Oilers legend robbed of a major honor in 1990 as new details surface


PUBLICATION
Daniel Lucente
August 24, 2026  (3:46 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

New York Rangers forward Wayne Gretzky (99) on the bench with forward Esa Tikkanen (10), forward Mark Messier (11), and defender Brian Leetch (2) against the Florida Panthers during the 1996-97 season at Miami Arena.
Photo credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Bill Ranford won the hardware in 1990, but a new look back argues Esa Tikkanen's shutdown work deserved serious Conn Smythe consideration too.

Every so often a debate from Oilers history gets dug back up, and this one still gets fans talking.
In 1990, Edmonton won its fifth Stanley Cup in seven years, a title run that came without Wayne Gretzky for the first time and still ended in a five game beatdown of Boston.
Bill Ranford took home the Conn Smythe Trophy as playoff MVP, and nobody would call that an undeserving pick.
He started all 22 games that spring, put together an eight game winning streak, and helped Edmonton climb out of a 3-1 hole in the opening round.
That's a legitimate case on its own.
But a resurfaced piece from Oilersnation makes the argument that Esa Tikkanen belonged in the conversation just as much.
Tikkanen spent that entire postseason getting under the skin of the league's best players, chasing down Gretzky himself in the second round before turning his attention to Chicago's stars and then Boston's Craig Janney in the final.
He didn't just shadow guys, he rattled them, turning would be offensive threats into non factors through four full rounds.

A two way weapon in a Cup run

It wasn't only shutdown work either.
Tikkanen chipped in offense throughout the run and was right there among Edmonton's scoring leaders that spring, all while being handed the toughest matchup on the other end of the ice nearly every night.
Few players in that era were trusted to do both jobs at once the way he was.

Why the debate still matters

Ranford's case is real and the trophy wasn't stolen from anybody.
Still, Tikkanen's fingerprints were all over that Cup, and in a league that increasingly values two way dominance, his 1990 run reads even better with three and a half decades of hindsight.
It's the kind of what if that keeps Oilers history fun to argue about.
POLL
2 HOURS AGO|9 ANSWERS
Edmonton Oilers legend robbed of a major honor in 1990 as new details surface

Do you think Esa Tikkanen deserved the 1990 Conn Smythe Trophy over Bill Ranford?


HOUSE OF HOCKEY
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT