POLLS     NHL     FACEBOOK

HOUSE OF HOCKEY


Brady and Matthew Tkachuk under fire for recent Leo Carlsson comments


PUBLICATION
Daniel Lucente
July 20, 2026  (9:35)
SHARE THIS STORY

Brady Tkachuk #7 of Team United States and Matthew Tkachuk #19 of Team United States celebrate after their game against Team Canada during the Milano Cortina 2026 Olympic Winter Games at Milano Santagiulia Ice Hockey Arena.
Photo credit: Geoff Burke-Imagn Images

Matthew and Brady Tkachuk called Carlsson's $18M deal an underpay.

The stat nobody's tracking is the clock on Brady's own next contract.
On the latest Wingmen podcast, Brady shrugged at the richest AAV in league history and said $18 million might end up an underpay.
Matthew agreed, adding that Carlsson is "worth like eight first-rounders."
"$18 million it's not an overpay whatsoever. Unbelievable, he comes as advertised, $18 million is probably going to be an underpay."

- Brady Tkachuk
Fair enough - Carlsson is elite, and the cap is climbing. But framing this as two stars admiring a peer misses the timing.
Brady becomes extension-eligible in roughly twelve months. Every dollar he can push into the center market now becomes his own comparable later.
That is the quiet self-interest here.
When the highest-paid player in the sport is called underpaid by the guy negotiating next, that is a floor being set, not a compliment being paid.

The Florida angle everyone is getting backwards

A second narrative claims that no one cares about the two brothers and added fuel to the mix.
That reads good but ignores the paper trail. The podcast friction that actually mattered happened in Ottawa, where Elliotte Friedman and Bruce Garrioch reported Wingmen wore on Brady's teammates before his June trade.
In Florida, the opposite is true.
Matthew has said GM Bill Zito pitched the podcast idea years ago.
The organization that supposedly hates the noise helped create it.

Why the comp matters more than the quote

Carlsson reset the ceiling. Macklin Celebrini and Connor Bedard are next, and both could clear $18 million when eligible.
Brady sits in that same wave, now on a contender with cap questions of his own. His underpay line is less a hot take on Anaheim than a preview of the raise he intends to command in Sunrise.
The story isn't that two brothers like a big contract. It's that one of them just publicly set the price of his own.
POLL
15 HOURS AGO|60 ANSWERS
Brady and Matthew Tkachuk under fire for recent Leo Carlsson comments

Was Brady's "underpay" comment really about setting up his own next contract?


HOUSE OF HOCKEY
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT