POLLS     NHL     FACEBOOK

HOUSE OF HOCKEY


Chris Johnston's Erik Karlsson update implicates the Maple Leafs


PUBLICATION
Alexander Cole
November 17, 2026  (6:59 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Erik Karlsson (65) shoots during the first period against the San Jose Sharks at SAP Center at San Jose.
Photo credit: Bob Kupbens-Imagn Images

Maple Leafs fans hoping for a splashy blue-line addition just received a reality check. Chris Johnston says Erik Karlsson makes sense for Toronto on paper, but the numbers and the timing do not line up.

On The Chris Johnston Show, the TSN insider confirmed the Pittsburgh Penguins defenceman has been part of the conversation in Toronto, then pumped the brakes.
There's been talk about Toronto, he makes sense for [them]; I don't know if the Leafs will be in a situation...where they can make the deal vis a vis the cap; and...it really depends how in it or not they are.

The Cap Problem

Karlsson is in the final year of an $11.5 million contract, though the San Jose Sharks retain $1.5 million, leaving a $10 million cap hit. He also holds a full no-movement clause.
For a Leafs team already tight against the ceiling, fitting that salary would take real roster surgery. Even a one-year rental would require Toronto to shed a comparable amount of salary first.
The 36-year-old is playing like a player worth the trouble. He leads Pittsburgh with 19 points, including 16 assists, in 19 games for a Penguins club sitting 7-10-2.

Are the Leafs Really Buyers?

Johnston's second concern is appetite. Toronto is 8-12-2 after a winless six-game homestand that ended with a 1-0 loss to the Edmonton Oilers.
General manager John Chayka has been working the phones to upgrade his defence, but paying a premium for a rental while the team sits nine points out of a wild-card spot is a difficult sell.
Chayka has also backed coach Jim Hiller and said the blue line needs help, yet a short-term fix may not fit the long-term plan Toronto is reportedly after.
The Carolina Hurricanes are viewed as a more natural landing spot, and Pittsburgh is reportedly not expected to formally open Karlsson's market before the new year.
That gives Toronto several weeks to decide whether it is a buyer or a seller. If the losing continues, the answer may make itself.
POLL
17 HOURS AGO|32 ANSWERS
Chris Johnston's Erik Karlsson update implicates the Maple Leafs

Do you believe the Maple Leafs will trade for Erik Karlsson?


HOUSE OF HOCKEY
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT