It's hard to fault McDavid entirely when one reflects on the context: an excruciating loss had just occurred, and his attention was much more on his team than any personal recognition. The loss of the Stanley Cup hung heavy emotionally, and at that moment, McDavid opted to share in his teammates' grief rather than celebrate his individual achievement. For him, the camaraderie in the locker room meant far more than any sort of trophy. In many ways, it spoke volumes to his leadership. He chose unity over individual praise of what it really means to be a captain. NHL Insider
Elliotte Friedman later reported just how emotional the scene was inside the Oilers' locker room, really underscoring just how bonded McDavid is to his teammates. While a lot of eyes pointed controversy at that, his decision indeed came with deep, deep loyalty and leadership.